Appeal Court

Appeal Court rules against Chief Justice

The Appeal Court has ruled in favour of the Law Association's appeal against a judge's decision to shut down its investigation into allegations of misconduct against Chief Justice Ivor Archie.

The ruling was handed down unanimously by acting Chief Justice Allan Mendonca and Justices of Appeal Peter Jamadar and Nolan Bereaux in the Appeal Court today.

The Appeal Court judges also dismissed Archie's judicial review application.

Persad-Bissessar welcomes Appeal Court ruling on Property Tax

Opposition Leader Kamla Persad-Bissessar is welcoming today's ruling in the Appeal Court on property tax.

Persad-Bissessar says the ruling is consistent with what the Opposition has been saying all along.

The following is a statement she issued today:

"We welcome the Orders made by the Court of Appeal directing the Commissioner of Valuations to clarify that the demand by the Government for citizens to submit the Valuation Return Form (“VRF”) and supporting documents is purely voluntary.

PM on Appeal Court rulings: Opposition attempted to create chaos

Prime Minister Dr Keith Rowley has lashed out against members of the Opposition he believes are using the court to "further their political gains" and has vowed that the government will fight every such legal battle all the way to the Privy Council.

Dr Rowley was speaking at today's post-Cabinet media conference, soon after the Appeal Court delivered a judgement allowing the State to resume collection of property tax valuation forms.

It was the second judgement by the Appeal Court in two days, favouring the State.

Appeal Court gives Gov't green light to resume collection of Property Tax forms

Government has been given the green light to resume its collection and processing of valuation return forms required for the calculation of property tax.

In an oral ruling at the Hall of Justice this morning, Appellate Judges Peter Jamadar, Gregory Smith and Judith Jones dismissed injunctions granted by Justice Frank Seepersad on the eve of the original deadline for submission of the forms last month.

UNC goes to Privy Council following Appeal Court's decision

President Anthony Carmona is now free to swear in two new High Court Judges after the Court of Appeal struck out an injunction blocking the appointments originally scheduled for yesterday.

Delivering a unanimous oral decision at the Hall of Justice in Port-of-Spain yesterday, Appellate Judges Allan Mendonca, Nolan Bereaux and Peter Rajkumar dismissed the injunction which was granted by High Court Judge Frank Seepersad to attorneys representing former agriculture minister Devant Maharaj, following a late night court sitting almost 12 hours earlier.

US loses in Appeal Court in bid to be part of Warner extradition case

An Appeal Court panel headed by Chief Justice Ivor Archie and including Appeal Justices Allan Mendonca and Peter Jamadar, unanimously ruled today against the US Government in its appeal in the Judicial Review matter associated with the extradition case against Jack Warner.

A written judgment was penned by Justice Mendonca, to which CJ Archie and Justice Jamadar expressed agreement. 

Persad-Bissessar: Appeal Court ruling a victory for democracy

Opposition Leader Kamla Persad-Bissessar has described the decision of the Appeal Court to dismiss the election appeal. as "a victory for democracy".

Three appeal judges upheld the High Court's decision that saw the election results remain the same.

She says the UNC respects the ruling of the court.

The following is Persad-Bissessar's statement.

Pages